
Originally Posted by
pArkEr
Plot holes? No, it just requires a bit of thought from yourself. LOST isn't a show that spoon-feeds its audience, it gives them questions and leaves these questions open to interpretation. The writers made it quite clear that they were only going to answer the mysteries that mattered, and they did (the smoke monster, the numbers, Jacob, and why they were brought to the island). Everything else... up for you to decide. Just read some of the theories on the net, and you'll understand why I made the comparison between Inception.
They weren't in purgatory, the 'alternative timeline' was purgatory. The main story actually happened.
If they made everything up, explain the Adam and Eve skeletons. Or again, the numbers. The statue. Nope, I think they had the main plot mapped out pretty well. Some stuff they added on as they went along, like Ben and the purgatory timeline. Also, there's a bonus scene on The Complete Lost Experience DVD involving Walt, which I'd like to get a hold of.
I'd like to add that, at the end of the day, LOST has always been about the characters, not the mythology surrounding it. So I think you're trying a bit too hard to hate on it, just like I'm trying a bit too hard to defend it :P
EDIT: I loved the finale. The whole purgatory thing wasn't executed all that well, but it did well to give a bit of closure. And while the final scene we all saw coming from season 1, it was nevertheless deeply moving.